Here’s a super smashing punching sweating panting tension filled film noir boxing drama starring Robert Ryan as the aging human punch bag, Bill “Stoker” Thompson. What a film The Set-Up turned out to be and it popped my 40’s cherry on this here blog.
Stoker is a proud tough man but unfortunately on a loosing streak and what with his age, his manager Tiny (George Tobias) takes a big bet out with local ringside gangster Little Boy (Alan Baxter) for Stoker to take a fall against his next opponent, the leaner and younger Tiger Nelson (Hal Baylor). Stupidly his manager at the Paradise City boxing club doesn’t let Stoker in on his bet because our hero has other plans..
Stoker has his “Adrian“, his doting wife Julie (Audrey Totter), a gal he so wants to impress. He wants to earn some dollar and set up a cigar stand or maybe become a trainer, Julie just wants him to stop before he gets beaten senseless, loses his memory or even worse, ends up dead!
Julie – I Want a Man… Not a Human Punching Bag!
In a just brilliant locker scene, you see all the boxers getting ready to fight, the fear, excitement, anxiety and bravery. Some go out scared and come back winners, others return with the cocky smile wiped off their faces. Stoker sits there absorbing all the energy in the room, slowly psyching himself up to take out his opponent.
If only Julie was there to watch him like she always does but she is dealing with her own future.
When the bell rings the heads go crunch, fist slamming body blows, twisting hips and flying uppercuts and jabs rain down across the ring. What expires is a truly righteous fight, a fight that takes up half the film!
Can Stoker fight without Julie as his inspiration? Will he be able to beat the Tiger? If he does, what does that mean? Or will he just end up with a bumbling messed up mind? It’s a very recommend watch. Have you seen it? or if you do, let me know your thoughts.
Lots of observations on this film so here goes…….
Both Robert Ryan and Hal Baylor measure up to 6′ 4″ and both accomplished boxers. The choreographed fight scenes are some of the best I’ve ever seen especially for the time. You are there, ring side all the way. It’s an epic fight that looks so incredibly realistic that they must of really been beating seven bells of shit out of each other.
Hal Baylor plays the giant rosy cheeked bouncer Michael in A Boy And His Dog
Director Robert Wise has a bonkers film list he’s made from classics like West Side Story and The Sound Of Music. To some of my favourite films like The Andromeda Strain, Run Silent Run Deep and the first Star Trek movie, which is still a feast for the eyes.
In a genius little move, the film is in real-time. You see a clock at different parts of the movie starting at 9.05pm to panning out to 10.16pm. What a difference a little over an hour can do!
The Set-Up is based on a screenplay adaptation of a long poem by Joseph Moncure March. The one big thing they changed was the protagonist’s race, originally he was a black guy going under the name of Pansy Jones. I read that black actor Canada Lee, also a boxer, was possible for the role. On a search I see Canada Lee played a boxer in the film Body and Soul 1947 (Now on my watch list). Robert Ryan completely smashes his part and you can’t see anyone else in that role but how amazing if the studio had the balls to cast a black actor in the lead role.
Now I need to see the boxing film made in the same year starring Kirk Douglas Champion.
Right I’ve blabbed on too much! Mikey Wolfman says “Have big fun at the movies”

Stunning French version of the film poster
Excellent film. I think this features on of Robert Ryan’s best screen performances (never seen him give a bad one). Sad, bleak and gripping. This is a film that lets the actors tell the story and the film takes its time. Looks incredible visually too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m slowly making my way through Robert Ryan’s movies and you’re so right, he does give such fine performances. I was so impressed with this one and looks like I’ve added to my watch list with some more film noir boxing dramas. Can’t wait to see them. Thank you for the comment Maddy 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you are checking out Robert’s work I recommend Odds Against Tomorrow. God’s Little Acre. The Naked Spur. On Dangerous Ground.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh sweet indeed. I’m on all four of these.
They all sound excellent, esp looking forward to “Odds Against Tomorrow” with Harry Belafonte and “On Dangerous Ground” was also recommend to me after I did a post on Ida Lupino “Hitch-Hiker”. I had tonight viewing sorted I thought but now you have thrown a spanner in the works hehe. Decisions.
Thank you for the heads up on Mr Ryan. Very much appreciated and a very happy Wolfie 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
My pleasure. Enjoy his work!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m can never understand why The Set-up isn’t talked about in the same hushed tones as films like Night in the City. Robert Ryan’s performance packs one hell of a punch and the pacing, the anticipation, and the dread simply don’t let up.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Paul you hit the nail on the head perfectly. It certainly does pack a punch in more ways than one. I’m still can’t stop thinking about it and spent last night telling friends to get on it. So much I loved about it. Yep indeed Robert Ryan was sublime. I recently saw Night In The City too. Oh my that was amazing too. The beauty of being pretty new to noir is I’m having a fantastic time 🙂 Thanks for the comment
LikeLike
I have now one question for you… could you tell me a couple of names that fall under this criteria: visually interesting (his is especially important, something surreal, avantgarde, weird too), made before 70-s, preferably in colour, both short/long is fine
LikeLike
The Set-up isn’t surreal or weird in anyway just an excellent scripted and paced drama.
Like wise would be something like The Killing (1956) Night And The City (1950) or Pickup on South Street (1953)
If surreal weird pre 70’s you after you could try….
https://wolfmanscultfilmclub.wordpress.com/2017/05/21/the-exterminating-angel-1962-sacrificial-lamb-satire/
https://wolfmanscultfilmclub.wordpress.com/2017/01/15/the-swimmer-1968/
A big fav but I’ve not done a post on yet “Seconds” http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0060955/?ref_=nv_sr_5
Only Swimmer in colour though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks!
LikeLike
Magnificent film and one of Ryan’s best. He’s had a resurgence in recent years thanks in large part to TCM. Along with Mitchum, a bona fide poster boy for Noir flicks. My initial thoughts on Ryan were mostly negative cause as a kid he was a real SOB in The Dirty Dozen but then The Wild Bunch started to change my mind and then I discovered Noir. When I started reading this I was thinking you’ll need to see Champion and Body and Soul….lol… see you already mentioned them.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Same bro same. I always thought he was always the bad guy. Especially after only pretty recently watching Bad Day at Black Rock. He is so incredible in the set up. I was in that film hook line and sinker. I felt his pain. Only last night I watched, yet another nod from you, “Act Of Violence”. He may of not been the main part but man was he excellent and another film that blew me away. I’m about to make a beeline to the films of Robert Mitchum. I’ve seen a few but need to get on the noir stuff. I have “Crossfire” and “Out of the Past” and have been recommended “The Racket”. Need to get on that train.
ps I do hope you and your family are having a lovely holiday. All the best.
LikeLike
I love the twist in Act of Violence with the goodie Heflin being the true villain. Mitchum rocks ibn our house. Just last week me and number 2 son Kirk watched The Yakuza. His first viewing and he was blown away. That’s why my boys listen to the Old Man. Just returned home last night and had a great time in the Rockies. Amazing country to see up close. Thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Haha no way!!!! Oh weird! I was going to watch The Yakuza last but it got a bit late for a 2hr film and went for something shorter. Now seeing that you mention it is all a bit twilight zone. This weekend it is penciled back in. Can’t wait as I don’t know nothing about it apart from it’s Mitchum and Yakuza! Has to be the best film in the world 🙂
Great to hear you had a superb time on your hols.
LikeLike
More than confident you’ll love it. Mitchum for me has always been the king of cool on screen. One step ahead of McQueen and Dino.https://mikestakeonthemovies.com/2016/02/07/robert-mitchum-just-naturally-eases-himself-into-cool-movie-poster-art/
LikeLike
“The Yakuza” Oh yes indeed I enjoyed it Mike. A slow burner but so worth the build up and what an ending. Post to come 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ll look forward to it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
[…] I watched all these superb films of his, Act Of Violence (1949), Bad Day at Black Rock (1955), The Set-Up (1949) On Dangerous Ground (1951), Executive Action (1973) and Men In War […]
LikeLike
[…] first Star Trek movie, which is still a feast for the eyes. Also the incredible noir boxer drama The Set-Up also starring Robert […]
LikeLike
[…] best sci-fi’s going The Day The Earth Stood Still (1951), one of the best boxing noir’s The Set-Up (1949). Then there’s submarine drama in Run Silent Run Deep (1958), classic musicals in West […]
LikeLike
[…] to cross. As I learnt about film noir from the countless must watch noir lists I stumbled across, The Set Up (1949) would be punched near the top. I watched it, reviewed it, fell instantly in love with it. […]
LikeLike
[…] will flippantly say it has some common ground in similar style to Robert Wise’s incredible, The Set Up (1949). With it’s focus firmly on the fighters getting ready to enter the arena. Anyone who’s […]
LikeLike